• Arnon Bar-On Department of Social Work, University of Botswana Gaborone, Botswana



Ever since Western social work was exported to Africa an ongoing debate has been taking place on whether it fits the African context. Most of this debate, however, has revolved around Western social work’s techniques rather than on its ends, which, being predicated on Western values, are likely to be alien to many Africans. The article outlines the arguments why Africa might require a form of social work of its own and the chances of such indigenisation taking place. It concludes, however, that while indigenisation may be a desirable end, it is probably impossible unless African social workers can engage in reflective learning with their clients.Common sense, presumably a universal trait, suggests that people behave differently in different situations and, as a corollary, that they require different types of knowledge that befit these situations. Most people, for example, conduct themselves differently at home and elsewhere and adapt their clothing and behaviour differently to formal and informal occasions. Equally apparent is that similar differences apply to people who live in different circumstances and, partly as a result, entertain different conceptions of the good. Thus, children in a resource-strapped school, who must share pencils in class, are more likely to develop interdependent outlooks than their counterparts in richer schools. Indeed, so self-evident are such observations that they beg the question why a practical pursuit like social work, as distinguished from more theory-oriented disciplines, must examine them at all?Or is this so? Recent years have seen a sharp rise in social workers being accused of skirting this common sense by ignoring the specific, lived-in experiences of many of their clients and consequently of being largely ineffective. Among these concerns are the negatively labelled "anti-racist", "anti-sexist", "anti-oppressive" and "anti-agist" prescriptions that increasingly imbue Western social work writings, and the more positively labelled "indigenisation" movement that emanates more from developing countries. This article examines the latter’s apprehensions, mainly as presented by African scholars, arguing that while its reasoning is self-evident, effective transformation of this reasoning into professional practice is often impossible. The article that follows this exposition (MW/SW 38(4) pages 311 - 323), by Kwaku Osei-Hwedie, contests this position in maintaining that the development of indigenous African social work knowledge and practices are possible.


Download data is not yet available.


AGOUBA, MI 1976. Social realities and the response of social work education in Africa. In: Realities and aspiration of social work education in Africa, document of the 3rd Conference of the Association for Social Work Education in Africa, Addis Ababa, April 3–12, ASWEA Document 11:86-112.

ALMANZOR, A 1967. The profession of social work in the Philippines. In: Council on Social Work Education, An intercultural exploration: Universals and differentials in social work values, functions and practice. New York: Council on Social Work Education.

ANDERSON, SC; WILSON, MK; MWANSA, L-K & OSEI-HWEDIE, K 1994. Empowerment and social work education and practice in Africa. Journal of Social Development in Africa, 9(2):71-86.

AUSTIN, DM 1983. The Flexner Myth and the history of social work. Social Service Review, September:357-377.

BAR-ON, A 2001. When assumptions on fieldwork education fail to hold: the experience of Botswana. Social Work Education, 20(1):123-136.

BEST, G 1995. Justice, international relations and human rights. International Affairs, 71(4):775-800.

BRADBURY, M 1995. What was post-modernism? The arts in and after the Cold War. International Affairs, 71(4):763-74.

BRANSCOMBE, M 1961. Curriculum planning for social work in newly developing countries. International Social Work, 4(3):1-3.

BRAUNS, H & KRAMER, D 1986 Social work education in Europe. Frankfurt: Eigenverlag des Deutches Vereins für Offentliche und Private Fursorge.

BROWN, M 1957. Where do we go from here?. Social Service Quarterly, 31:112-116.

CARR-SAUNDERS, AM & WILSON, PA 1933. The professions. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

CLARKSON, EM 1974. The contribution of casework to development. International Social Work, 17(3):43-49.

CLARKSON, EM 1976. The contribution of British social work to developing countries. International Social Work. 19(1):3-6.

CLIFFORD, W 1966. A primer of social casework in Africa. Nairobi: Oxford University Press.

DESAI, SF 1974. Zoroastrianism: Its ideology and social work values. Social Work and Development Newsletter, 11.

DIXON, J & SCHEURELL, RP (eds) 1995. Social welfare with indigenous peoples. London: Routledge.

DOMINELLI, M 1997. Sociology for social work. Houndmills, Basingstock: Macmillan.

Social Work/Maatskaplike Werk 2003:39(1)

DUNNING, DW 1972. Limits to the amount of noise. International Social Work, 15(2):4-7.

ELLIOT, D 1993. Social work and social development: towards an integration model for social work practice. International Social Work, 36(1):21-36.

ELLIS, A 1979. The practice of rational emotive therapy: Theoretical and empirical foundations of RET. Montery, California: Brooks Cole.

FLEXNER, A 1915. Is social work a profession? Proceedings of the National Conference on Charities and Correction, 1915. Chicago: Hildmann Printing Co:576-590.

FLEXNER A 1940. I Remember. New York: Simon & Schuster.

GOODE WJ 1969. The theoretical limits of professionalization. In: ETZIONI, A The semi-professions and their organization. New York: Free Press.

GORE, MS 1967. The cultural perspective in social work in India. In: Council on Social Work Education, An intercultural exploration: Universals and differentials in social work values, functions and practice. New York: Council on Social Work Education.

GRAY, M; MAZIBUKO, F & O’BRIEN, F 1996. Social work education for social development. Journal of Social Development in Africa, 11(1):33-42.

GRAY, M 1998. Developmental social work: Theory and practice. Cape Town: David Philip.

GREENWOOD, E 1957. Attributes of a profession. Social Work, 2(3):45-55.

GUZZELLA, C 1996. The decline of the North American model of social work. International Social Work, 39(3):301-315.

HAMMOUD, HR 1988. Social work education in developing countries: issues and problems in undergraduate curricula. International Social Work, 31:195-210.

HOEY, JM 1954. Professional implications of international social work development. In: KASIUS, C (ed) New directions in social work. New York: Harper.

HOLLISTER, CD & JONES, JF 1977. Education for social development. In: SPECHT, H & VICKERY, A (eds) Integrated social work methods, London: Allen and Unwin.

HUANG, K 1978. Matching needs with services: shoes for Chinese feet. International Social Work, 21:44-54.

HUTTON, M 1992. Social work: An extension of community. Inaugural Lecture. Gaborone: University of Botswana.

HUTTON, M 1994. Reshaping the social work curriculum: an African experience. Paper presented at the conference of the International Association of Schools of Social Work, Amsterdam, July.

IFE, J 2000. Local and global practice: Relocating social work as a human rights profession in the new global order. European Journal of Social Work, 4:5-15.

ILLIFE, J 1987. The African poor: A history. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

International Social Work 1972. Editorial, 15(4).

KAUSIKAN, B 1993. Asia’s different standard. Foreign Policy, 92:24-41.

KENDALL, K (ed.) 1971. Population dynamics and family planning: A new responsibility for social work education. New York: Council on Social Work Education.

KHINDUKA, S 1971. Social work in the Third World. Social Service Review, 45:62-73.

LASAN, DB 1975. Indigenisation with a purpose. International Social Work, 18(1):20-32.

LOUW, LR 1998. Changing social welfare policy in South Africa. Social Work/Maatskaplike Werk, 34(1):134-143.

MAN, KW 1996. Empowerment practice in social work: the case of Hong Kong. In: PARSLOE, P (ed) Pathways to Empowerment. Birmingham: Venture Press.

MAN, KW undated. Local knowledge, indigenous practice: linking the cultural, the personal, and the professional in social work practice (mimeographed).

MANYIRE, H & ASINGWIIRE, N 1996. The state and dynamics of social policy practice and research in Uganda. A research report prepared as part of the Regional Project for Social Policy Practice and Research in Eastern and Southern Africa. Kampala: Makerere University.

MARSLAND, D 1996. Welfare or welfare state? Contradictions and dilemmas in social policy. Basingstoke: Macmillan.

McKENDRICK, BW 1988. Learning from the past, building for the future: The transformation of social welfare and social work in South Africa. Editorial. Social Work/Maatskaplike Werk, 34(1):i-iii.

MIDGLEY, J 1981/1992. Professional imperialism: Social work in the Third World. Studies in Social Policy and Welfare, XVI. Aldershot: Avebury.

MIDGLEY, J 1992. Is international social work a one-way transfer of idea and practice methods from the United States to other countries? – Yes. In: GAMBRILL, E & PRUGER, R (eds) Controversial Issues in Social Work. Boston: Allyn and Bacon.

MIDGLEY, J 1995. Social development: The developmental perspective in social welfare. London: Sage.

MIDGLEY, J; HALL, A; HARDIMAN, M & NARINE, D 1986. Community participation, development and the state. London: Methuen.

MUPEDZISWA, R 1992. Africa at a crossroads: major challenges for social work education and practice towards the year 2000. Journal of Social Development in Africa, 7(2):19-38.

MUPEDZISWA, R 1996. The challenge of economic development in an African developing country: social work in Zimbabwe. International Social Work, 39(1):41-54.

MUPEDZISWA, R 1977. Training social workers in an environment of economic reforms: The "mother" of all challenges? Social Work/Maatskaplike Werk, 33(3):233-243.

MUTISO, R 1979. Developmental social work. Journal for social work education in Africa, 3:17-24.

MUZALLE, P 1987. Social development, rural poverty and implications for fieldwork practice. Journal of Social Development in Africa, 2(1):75-87.

MWANSA, L-K 1992. Radical social work practice: the case for Africa. Paper presented at the Department of Social Work’s National Field Supervisors’ Seminar. Ramatea, Kanye, Botswana, 27-29 March.

MWANSA, L-K 1996. Contemporary issues facing the social work profession in Southern Africa. Paper presented at the Joint Universities Committee Conference. Magoebasloof, 9-12 September.

NAGPAUL, H 1972. The diffusion of American social work education to India. International Social Work, 15(1):3-17.

NANN, R 1989. Social work - local and global: a look at social work across ideologies and culture. Inaugural Lecture. Hong Kong: Department of Social Work and Social Administration, University of Hong Kong.

NGWENYA, B 1992. Social work in Botswana: the agony of irrelevance. Gaborone: University of Botswana (mimeographed).

NIMMAGADDA, J & COWGER CD 1999. Cross-cultural practice: social worker ingenuity in the indigenization of practice knowledge. International Social Work, 42(3):261-276.

NORTH, M 1972. The secular priests. London: Allen & Unwin.

NTUSI, TM 1998. Professional challenges for South African social workers: Response to recent political changes. Social Work/Maatskaplike Werk, 34(4):380-388.

OSEI-HWEDIE, K 1993. The challenge of social work in Africa: starting the indigenisation process. Journal of Social Development in Africa, 8(1):19-30.

OSEI-HWEDIE, K 1995a. A search for legitimate social development education and practice models for Africa. Lewiston, New York: Edwin Mullen.

OSEI-HWEDIE, K 1995b. The indigenisation of social work practice and education in Africa: the dilemma of theory and method. Paper presented at the Conference of Social Work Educators and Practitioners. University of Cape Town, Cape Town, 11-13 September.

OSEI-HWEDIE, K 1995c. Southern African regional approaches to indigenising social work education and practice: the case of Botswana. Paper presented at the Institute for Indigenous Theory and Practice Workshop: Indigenising Social Work Education and Practice. Cape Technikon, Cape Town, 16-18 October.

OSEI-HWEDIE, K 1995d. Towards understanding the relationship between social work and social development in Africa. Paper presented on the establishment of the Association of Eastern and Southern African Schools of Social Work. Harare, 6 July.

OSEI-HWEDIE, K 1996. The indigenization of social work practice and education: vision or vanity? Inaugural Lecture, University of Botswana, 25 September.

PARAISO, V 1966. Education for social work in Latin America. International Social Work, 9(2):19-20.

PAREKH, B 2000. Rethinking multiculturalism: Cultural diversity and political theory. Hounmills: Basingstoke: Macmillan.

PIKE, KL 1967. Language in relation to a unified theory of the structure of human behaviour. (2nd rev ed) The Hague: Mouton.

RADITLHOKWA, L 1993. Government must revamp welfare services to curb social problems. The Botswana Gazette, 12 May:9.

RADITLHOKWA, L 1994. Time to break the passive cycle. Higher Education Development Unit Bulletin, Gaborone: University of Botswana, 11 October:8-9.

RAMSEY, G 2001. An African-centred perspective on counselling: A search for understanding. University of Birmingham: Department of Theology. (PhD Dissertation)

RANKIN, P 1997. Developmental social welfare: Challenges facing South Africa. Social Work/Maatskaplike Werk, 33(3):184-192.

RESNICK, RP 1976. Conscientization: an indigenous approach to international social work. International Social Work, 19(2):21-9.

ROBERTSON, JM 1963. Observations on some aspects of social work education in developing countries. International Social Work, 6(2):19-21.

ROTH, JA 1974. Professionalism: the sociologist’s decoy. Sociology of Work and Occupations, 1:6-23.

RWOMIRE, A & RODITLHOKWA, L 1996. Social work in Africa: issues and challenges. Journal of Social Development in Africa, 11(2):5-19.

SHAWKEY, A 1972. Social work education in Africa. International Social Work, 15(3):3-16.

SILAVWE, GW 1995. The need for a new social work perspective in an African setting: the case of Zambia. British Journal of Social Work, 25(1):71-84.

TOORS, M 1992. Is international social work a one-way transfer of idea and practice methods from the United States to other countries? - No. In: GAMBRILL, E & PRUGER, R (eds) Controversial Issues in Social Work. Boston: Allyn and Bacon.

UNITED NATIONS, 1971. Training for social welfare: Fifth international survey. New York: United Nations.

UNITED NATIONS DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME (UNDP) 2002. Human Development Report. New York: Oxford University Press.

WALTON, RG & ABO EL NASR, MM 1988. Indigenisation and authentization in terms of social work in Egypt. International Social Work, 31:135-44.

WOOTTON, B 1959. Social science and social pathology. London: Allen & Unwin.

YIMAN, A 1976. The need for social development training in a changing Africa. Journal for Social Work Education in Africa, 2(2):5-13




How to Cite